Discord between the shareholders of a real-estate company (SCI): the solutions
October 13th 2017(Cour de cassation (French Civil Supreme Court), 3rd Chamber, February 23, 2017)
The discord between shareholders may result in an early dissolution
The discord between shareholders may constitute a potential major risk for the company, which may result in its operational standstill.
In such case, the French Civil Code (Article 1844-7 5°) provide that the Court may pronounce the early dissolution of the company.
In a case dated February 23, 2017, the Cour de cassation (the French Civil Supreme jurisdiction) recently reasserted the principle according to which in order for the company’s dissolution to be pronounced, the discord must result in its operational standstill.
In practice, this standstill is characterized, in particular, when the discord renders any collective decision impossible.
The company’s operational standstill
In the Cour de cassation case, the SCI’s operational standstill was established as follows:
- the SCI was setup between two shareholders holding the same number of shares, one of whom was the manager;
- the situation of discord, the origin of which dates back to the termination of the professional relations between both shareholders over a third party company, and had existed for four (4) years on the date of decision by the
Tribunal de Grande Instance, which pronounced the company’s early termination; - the manager of the SCI had initiated court actions (civil and criminal) against his co-shareholder;
- the manager had unilaterally signed a sale agreement for land belonging to the company, infringing the by-laws which stipulated that the sale of
real-estate assets should first be authorized by all the shareholders; - the absence for several years of any ordinary collective decision deciding on the allocation of the company’s results.
On this basis, the Cour de cassation confirms that the Court of Appeal had legally justified its decision, by deducting that the discord between the shareholders caused an operational standstill for the SCI, on the grounds of the different reasons set forth above.
The solutions to prevent the standstill
A conflictual context between shareholders, whether they are majority, minority, operational or investing shareholders, makes it difficult to reach adequate solutions, as a balance has to be found between the consideration of the conflicting shareholders and the company’s interest.
The risk of the company’s operational standstill, enhanced in the presence of shareholders carrying the same number of voting rights, is rarely taken into consideration by the founding partners when they setup the company and most often the by-laws do not offer any viable solution.
In order to prevent the ultimate consequence of the company’s compulsory dissolution, a certain number of mechanisms may be used at each stage of a conflict, to implement solutions to demine the shareholders’ discord, amongst which:
- Anticipation of the conflict by setting up exit and amicable resolution clauses for conflicts stipulated in a shareholders’ agreement.
- A pedagogical approach for the parties to reach a conciliation and setup of the consequential legal operations (sale of shares and securities, capital reduction, etc.).
- Setup of mediation solutions, led by an authorized third party.
- Initiation of court proceedings before the relevant courts.
These solutions must be used appropriately in order to protect the relevant interests (conflicting shareholders, the company) given the specific nature of the discord.
- The director’s obligation of loyalty in the sale of shares…
- Commercial leases: a limitation to the refusal of the lease renewal for irregularity of the sub-lease
- Dividends paid to spouses under community of property: to whom must they be paid?
- Ydès advises Vente-privee.com for change of control in Vente-exclusive.com
- Ydès advises Vente-privee.com for equity acquisition in Misterfly
- A director’s misconduct separable from duties
- Ydès advises Custom Solutions for stake acquisition in Incentive Office - Highten
- Ydès advises Erta Alé Développement (holding company of Voyageurs du Monde’s department “adventure travels”)
- Representations and warranties exercised in spite of the awareness of defects by the beneficiary
- The confidentiality of the income statement is extended to “Small Companies”
- The sudden termination of established business relations: consequences of the transfer of the business
- Reserve of ownership clause and sub-purchaser
- The digital deed by attorney
- Merger: conditions of modification by the shareholders
- The powers to commit a company
- Marc Chaudet is appointed as partner in the Corporate practice of Ydès
- Ydès advises Vente-privee.com in its external growth operations in Switzerland and Spain (eboutic.ch and Privalia)
- The general manager’s liability and general meeting
- Ydès advises Asobo Studios on its partnership in the USA
- Ydès on the new equity financing round of MisterFly
- Décideurs 2016 ranking: the Ydès teams in a league of their own
- Ydès advises Designers Guild for the leasing of their new Parisian showroom
- Ydès has assisted Vente-privee.com for equity investment in Adotmob
- Marcelo Mazzilli is appointed as partner in the Corporate practice of Ydès
- Ydès has assisted the sellers in the context of the sale of the French company Sitco Groupe to the Italian group Arti Grafiche Reggiane & Lai
- IFLR1000 2017 ranking: Ydès stands out in M&A and private equity
- Ydès advises Vente-privee.com in the context of its international development in Poland
- Ydes has advised MBO Partenaires
- Ydès will be attending Mipim 2017
- Ydes will host in Lyon advoc European Annual General Meeting.
- Ydes Avocats advises Vente-privee.com in its investment in Le Petit Ballon
- Décideurs 2017 ranking: the Ydès teams in a league of their own
- Ydes advised Alma Bio Therapeutics in a fundraising with Wiseed, Delphi Genetics and business angels
- Discord between the shareholders of a real-estate company (SCI): the solutions
- Ydès will be attending Mapic 2017
- Ydès will be attending Mipim 2018
- Ydes advises Groupe Adequat in the context of its international developement in Canada
- Ydes advises Sokaral and the Managers, in the acquisition of Aluthea Group
- Ydes advises Groupe Adequat in the context of its international development in Ireland
- Ydès wishes you a happy new year 2019 !
- Ydès will attend the 7th IBA European Corporate & Private M&A Conference in Paris!
- BIM...a priority for Ydès
- Ydès Avocats has advised UI Gestion and Gault & Fremont in the acquisition of Emballages du Dauphiné et Daujas
- Ydès Avocats advised Vente-privee.com as part of the sale to the Fimalac group of three parisian theaters